TEN DAYS OF PROGRESS – KNIT METHOD COMPARISON

Coming to the end of our recuperative sojourn out in North Truro. I had hoped to post pix of the aurora from here, but sadly last night was heavily clouded, and windy. So I maintain my record of weather-related disappointment in relation to notable sky events.

But that doesn’t mean that nothing has been accomplished in the past week and a half. I’ve been knitting, stitching, and working on various book-related projects.

That’s four of the hat bodies for the frog hats done, with another about 40% done. That leaves only a couple more to go, then I will begin the army of eyeballs for them all.

One large skein of THE Herschnerr’s afghan yarn makes about four hats. I am not any more pleased with it for knitting than I was with it for crocheting (it’s leftover from the Eyeball Bolster). It squeaks and splits. And being mid-range acrylic, is not “heirloom quality.” But for a topical hat whose topicality won’t last long, and being on hand rather than a new purchase, it is good enough.

One thing I’ve done is to check my speed and uniformity across a range of knit-in-the-round methods. Counting from the upper right, Hat #1 was done using the Magic Loop method. That employs one overly long circular needle. The excess cable length is drawn out into a loop between two stitches roughly on the opposite side of the piece from the point where one is knitting. One works to that loop, then pulls the excess out to make a new loop 180-degrees from the loop that has just been encountered. For the record, I find it quite awkward, an annoying break in the rhythm of production, and prone to distending stitches.

Hat #2 was done using just one circular needle of as close a size to the circumference of the hat as I had in my collection. Round and round, yanking the stitches across the joins as I went. I didn’t enjoy this one either. I find that circs of that small size have needle parts that are not long enough for my overly large paws. My fingers might not be pianist long, but my hands are quite wide. I wear men’s size golf gloves because women’s gloves are too narrow. Hand size plus the way I hold my needles for Continental style work means that my ring and pinky fingers support the weight of the needles and the piece. Using a circular this short makes me grasp cable, not the sturdy needle parts. Harder to hold, harder to maintain unform stitches, and harder to form them at speed.

Hat #3 was worked entirely on DPNs. Now I’m more in my comfort zone. But being out here on the Cape I only brought my set of mismatched but brightly colored Boye aluminum DPNs. They are seven inches long (about 17.78cm). I much prefer my vintage European DPNs from Inox, which were 8 inches long (20cm). I should have grabbed them, but didn’t. The short Boyes worked well enough for the K2P2 ribbing, and I flew through that section, but when I changed to stockinette, the extra width of the knit fabric without the draw-in of the ribbing made keeping all the stitches on the needles a bit difficult. I had to stop to retrieve dropped stitches more often than I anticipated. That slowed me down and affected uniformity of stitches, even though I’m a proven DPN warrior.

Hat #4 was worked with two circulars. This is a hybrid method. Each circular holds half of the stitches. Using both ends of the first needle, you work the stitches across the front of the piece, then you switch to the other circular, and use both ends of it to work the stitches of the back. Unlike with DPNs where the needles travel around the work, with each DPN advancing to the next position as it is freed then employed for the next segment, the two circulars in this method NEVER change places. Yes, there is a bit of awkwardness as one fishes for the correct end to use and then moves stitches up into working position, but it is not as fiddly as Magic Loop. And unlike Magic Loop, there is no distortion between stitches because there is no spot where the cable loop has to be drawn out. I also found that the in between needle bits did not ladder, but that may be because as an experienced DPN jockey, I tensioned across the gap in the same way that I do where two DPNs meet. All in all this worked quite nicely, especially for the stockinette part.

Hat #5 (in process) will be the “best of both worlds” piece. I started it on DPNs for the ribbing – proven faster for me than the other methods, and moved to two circulars for the stockinette tube section – the best for maintaining sanity and uniformity given the needle assortment I have with me here on the road. I will probably continue on two circs for a while and then when it’s convenient, switch back to the DPNs for at least half of the crown. That will minimize the needle ends flailing around part when the decreases begin to make a major dent in total stitch count. In all probability I’ll keep working this mixed method way for the remaining few hats.

For the record, the eyeballs will all be done on DPNs in a smaller size than the hat bodies. I want them to be nice, tight spheres, suitable for stuffing. So instead of these 3.5mm needles I’ll be moving down to 2mms, or possibly even smaller. Much experimentation is anticipated.

Also in the photo is the latest progress on my Italian multicolor stitched piece. I’m well into the third corner, having done the math correctly (thank goodness). No need to improvise a new corner. I know the museum original had four different corners, but in this case I’m glad to have to do only one.

The long stretch across is next. I have confidence that I am not off in count, so everything should align when I get to corner #4 and the the shorter march to rejoin my point of origin, but in case it doesn’t that last corner is where any fudging will occur. In the mean time I will work with my usual mix of confidence and suspenseful apprehension, plotting out just-in-case strategies so I have them if needed.

And they say that needlework as a hobby has no drama… If only folk knew.

9 responses

  1. dana's avatar

    I also prefer DPNs when possible, and when the stitches start dropping off the ends, I have found that wrapping an elastic hair tie around the piece just under the needles helps considerably.

    1. kbsalazar's avatar

      I can see that the elastic would help stop the ends, but I work so fast on DPNs I would be spending more time attaching and removing them than actually working across the rows. A good solution, though!

      1. dana's avatar

        Sorry I wasn’t clear – wrapping the elastic around the whole tube of knitting to narrow the diameter, not around the needles themselves.

        1. kbsalazar's avatar

          Very interesting thought! Will have to try that. I have a hair clip that might work nicely, too. Thanks!

  2. pizzacasualbf29a7fa5f's avatar
    pizzacasualbf29a7fa5f | Reply

    Those are so cheerful and are going to be so much fun to wear!

  3. Anne C.'s avatar

    Your experimentation with different in-the-round methods matches mine–definitely not a fan of magic loop or the small circumference circs, so I use dpns or 2 circs for socks, hats, sleeves… I made a pair of socks using both methods, i.e., one sock on dpns, one on 2 circs, and was surprised to find that my gauge was tighter on the 2 circs.

    I’ve seen some photos of the northern lights from the Cape recently, and it’s the only thing that makes me sad we sold our house in Truro. It’s definitely a recuperative area, aurora or no, so here’s to your continued healing.

  4. Elaine in Oz's avatar

    Instead of magic loop, which always splits the round in the same place, I just pull out a loop of the excess cable somewhere near the RH needle, work to that point, then pull out some more further along the round, knit to there, etc etc. And switch to DPNs when the cable becomes too awkward.

    Aurora supposedly visible in Melbourne but we have a major 24-hour construction zone to our south and all we can see is the glare of their lights.

  5. Carolyn Priest-Dorman's avatar
    Carolyn Priest-Dorman | Reply

    Delighted to hear that I’m not the only person who dislikes Magic Loop!

    Looking forward to seeing the froggie hats evolve to their finished state.

  6. JustGail's avatar

    Awesome progress on both projects. My thought on keeping stitches on DPNs was to take a loop of elastic cord or narrow elastic, a wee bit smaller than the knitting, and figure-8 loop it over the needles. Just enough to keep the stitches together so they don’t fall off. By figure-8 loop I mean put the loop over the needle, make 1 twist and loop over the other end of the needle. Dana’s suggestion of wrapping a hair tie around the knitted part is interesting. If I ever learn to knit well enough to tackle DPNs, I hope I remember it.

    I wasn’t holding much hope on the lights, usually weather does not cooperate here. I was quite surprised when DH said they were visible.

Leave a reply to stayjohnston Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.